First of all, thank you so much for this clear and lucid presentation of the material. At 7:30, when Dr. Rodriguez illustrates the example of the complement of an open ball in R^2, he states that the set is neither closed nor convex -- I believe he meant to say that it is only non-convex (it would be closed by definition, as the complement of an open set in the usual metric topology) which would demonstrate the necessity of convexity; the minimum norm occurs across the boundary of the disk. If it were both closed and convex as a counterexample, we couldn't conclude that either property was necessary for the length-minimization property to hold. To show that being closed is also needed, we could also (in addition to Dr. Rodriguez's second example) take an open ball not centered at the origin: a unique minimum-norm element (some point closest to zero) would occur on its boundary, which the ball does not contain because that is its set of limit points.
2 месяца назад
jony stuck
Great Lecture!
2 месяца назад
Stirling Newberry
He is slow but packs a punch all the way to the end of the lecture.
Комментарии: 4
Ari Krishna
First of all, thank you so much for this clear and lucid presentation of the material. At 7:30, when Dr. Rodriguez illustrates the example of the complement of an open ball in R^2, he states that the set is neither closed nor convex -- I believe he meant to say that it is only non-convex (it would be closed by definition, as the complement of an open set in the usual metric topology) which would demonstrate the necessity of convexity; the minimum norm occurs across the boundary of the disk. If it were both closed and convex as a counterexample, we couldn't conclude that either property was necessary for the length-minimization property to hold. To show that being closed is also needed, we could also (in addition to Dr. Rodriguez's second example) take an open ball not centered at the origin: a unique minimum-norm element (some point closest to zero) would occur on its boundary, which the ball does not contain because that is its set of limit points.
2 месяца назадjony stuck
Great Lecture!
2 месяца назадStirling Newberry
He is slow but packs a punch all the way to the end of the lecture.
2 месяца назадk tayeb
your inf is a minimum ,because it is attained
Месяц назад